Can Trudeau put his stamp on the Supreme Court? That's not how it works here, say experts - Politics - Action.News ABC Action News Santa Barbara Calgary WestNet-HD Weather Traffic

Home WestNet.ca WebMail

    Regions
  • Local Traffic Report World Headlines WestNet Weather
  • Contact Action News

              

Updated: 13th July 2017 21:28

Can Trudeau put his stamp on the Supreme Court? That's not how it works here, say experts

Appointing a chief justice is 'the most important appointment a prime minister makes,' says Anne McLellan

By Peter Zimonjic, CBC News Posted: Jun 13, 2017 5:00 AM ET Last Updated: Jun 13, 2017 4:43 PM ET

Justice Beverley McLachlin is sworn in as a Supreme Court justice in 1989. Appointing new members to the Supreme Court has traditionally had more to do with geography than ideology.

Justice Beverley McLachlin is sworn in as a Supreme Court justice in 1989. Appointing new members to the Supreme Court has traditionally had more to do with geography than ideology. (Ron Poling/Canadian Press)

Related Stories

  • Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin retiring from Supreme Court
  • 'Brush up' on your French, justice minister says to Supreme Court hopefuls
  • Supreme Court officially welcomes Newfoundlander Malcolm Rowe as newest member
  • Justice Thomas Cromwell bids farewell to Supreme Court's weight of responsibility
  • Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin says judges should speak out about delays

The coming retirement of the chief justice of the Supreme Court could be seen by some as an opportunity for the prime minister to put his stamp on the institution, but experts say Canada's high court is almost impossible to steer in any given direction.

When the Supreme Court of Canada ruled in Feb. 2015 that denying a doctor-assisted death was unconstitutional, seven of the justices on the bench were appointees of former prime minister Stephen Harper.

When the same court struck down Canada's prostitution laws prohibiting brothels, living on the avails of prostitution and communicating in public with clients, five of the Supreme Court justices were Harper appointees.

"What more would Trudeau want out of a court?" asked Howard Anglin, Harper's former deputy chief of staff whose job was to advise the prime minister on whom to elevate to Canada's top court. "I don't think [Trudeau] needs to look to change the court to have the sort of court he would want."

  • Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin retiring from Supreme Court
  • Supreme Court says yes to doctor-assisted suicide in specific cases
  • Supreme Court strikes down Canada's prostitution laws

Regionally balanced

Part of the challenge in attempting to "stack" the Supreme Court, Anglin said, is that convention in Canada dictates two of the justices have to be from the West, one has to be from Atlantic Canada, and there have to be three each from Ontario and Quebec.

That means the pool of qualified candidates for each new position on the Supreme Court is drawn from a smaller group of regional candidates.

Once the qualified candidates are narrowed down, it becomes harder to choose someone who leans politically in one direction. A reason for that, he says, is because Canadian judges are not as political as they are in the U.S.

'Cabinet ministers, as we all know, come and go. But the chief justice, once appointed, will be there, bar unforeseen situations, up until mandatory retirement.' - Anne McLellan, former Liberal justice minister

"I don't think the function of the Supreme Court in Canada lends itself in the same way that it does in the U.S. where judges are obviously selected differently depending on whether the Democrats or Republicans are in office," former Supreme Court of Canada justice John Major told CBC News.

Major said that in his experience justices have remained largely non-political and therefore it's almost impossible for any one prime minister to put their stamp on the institution.

"Unless the philosophy of the court changes I don't think [Trudeau] can leave a mark on it," Major added.

Choosing a new chief justice

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has two immediate challenges. One is replacing Beverley McLachlin as the chief justice. Historically, the role of chief justice has been selected from among the remaining sitting justices, and that position almost always rotates between a justice from Quebec and the rest of Canada.

The one exception to that conventional practice is when Pierre Trudeau appointed Manitoba's Brian Dickson in 1984 to succeed Ontario's Bora Laskin as chief justice.

Justin Trudeau could decide to go that route and pick a chief justice that is not from Quebec, but as Anglin notes, when Trudeau flirted with the idea of not appointing the last Supreme Court justice from Atlantic Canada he faced widespread backlash and ended up appointing Malcolm Rowe from N.L.

SCOC Rowe 20161202

Justice Malcolm Rowe takes his place at the bench of the Supreme Court during a welcoming ceremony in December. Trudeau flirted with the idea of not appointing the last Supreme Court justice from Atlantic Canada, but ended up appointing Rowe, who is from Newfoundland and Labrador. (Fred Chartrand/Canadian Press)

"I think he would do well to avoid that and indicate right away that he would follow that precedent," said Anglin.

A question of leadership

Appointing a chief justice is "the most important appointment a prime minister makes," said Anne McLellan, A former federal Liberal justice minister under prime minister Jean Chrétien. "Cabinet ministers, as we all know, come and go. But the chief justice, once appointed, will be there, bar unforeseen situations, up until mandatory retirement."

Eugene Meehan, the former executive legal officer for the Supreme Court in the early 1990s, said that in choosing the next chief justice Trudeau would serve himself and the country better by picking a strong leader.

Task Force Cannabis 20161213

Anne McLellan says a prime minister shapes the court by making strong merit-based appointments. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

"It's not so much a prime ministerial stamp as an opportunity to place another solid judicial captain at the helm, to steer Canada's legal system into the decades ahead," he said.

McLellan agrees, saying the notion of putting a stamp on the Supreme Court is one not associated with Canada's legal system.

She said the way a prime minister shapes the court is by making strong merit-based appointments. She pointed to Chrétien's decision, when McLellan was justice minister, to make McLachlin Canada's first female chief justice based simply on what McLellan says was merit and competence.  

A new appointment process

If Trudeau promotes one of the other Supreme Court justices to chief justice, he then has to appoint someone to fill McLachlin's empty chair, which becomes more challenging when the prime minister has to limit himself to a candidate from the West.

McLachlin is from B.C. and there is some debate, Anglin says, as to whether the two Western Canadian seats on the court should be filled with a candidate from any of the four Western provinces or if one seat is specifically for B.C and the other is for Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba.

"I think he should look hard at someone from B.C. first, and only if he didn't find someone acceptable from B.C. should he look further, " said Anglin.

Complicating matters further is the new appointment process for Supreme Court justices announced in August of last year.

US Elxn Cda Women 20161108

Former prime minister Kim Campbell is chair of an independent advisory board that recommends a short-list of three to five candidates for the Supreme Court. (Jonathan Hayward/Canadian Press)

Former prime minister Kim Campbell has been named chair of an independent advisory board that recommends a short-list of three to five candidates to the prime minister for his consideration.

Those candidates come from a pool of bilingual lawyers or judges across Canada who applied to the high court.

"Trudeau has introduced an advisory process that will limit his own discretion," said Emmett Macfarlane, author of Governing from the Bench: The Supreme Court of Canada and the Judicial Role.

"A selection committee will be recommending him a set of names for consideration, so patronage and ideology are even less likely to dominate the process."

Corrections

  • This story has been edited to correct a reference to former prime minister Jean Chretien's appointment of Beverley McLachlin as Canada's first female chief justice of the Supreme Court. In an earlier version, the word "chief" was dropped. Bertha Wilson, appointed in 1982, was Canada's first female Supreme Court justice.

    Jun 13, 2017 4:33 PM ET

Articled from the CBC RSS Syndication CBC.ca - RSS Feeds Copyright is that of their respective owners (CBC) Calgary News Releases

Copyright 2014 WestNet-HD Action News

Email this story to a Friend!
Your Email :

Friend Email Address :

10 of the Best Anti-Racsim Ads

100 Container Ship Crashes

12 Reasons Chocolate Is Good for Your Health

13-of-earths-largest-sinkholes

1992 Toyota Supras For Sale

2000 Toyota Land Cruiser For Sale in Alberta

2008 Cadillac Escalade For Sale in Alberta

2015 Year In Review

2019 Toyota Supra Leaked Pictures and Specs - ACTION NEWS FIRST

30 Unbelievable Pictures Are Completely REAL not by Photoshop

ALEXANDRA STAN vs MANILLA MANIACS - All My People (Official Video)_(720p)

Abandoned, Asbestos Ridden Calgary Elementary School Torn Down

Alexandra Stan - Cliche (Hush Hush) OFFICIAL HD MUSIC VIDEO

Alexandra Stan - Mr Saxobeat (Official Video)

American Express Releases Platinum Metal Stainless Steel Card - Review -Action News Exclusive

BMW recalls 25,984,000 vehicles over turn signal problem

BREAKING NEWS - Florida Bridge Collapses ACTION NEWS FIRST

BREAKING NEWS - YouTube shooting - Female suspect dead at scene, upset over YouTube Account Suspension

Benefits of Buying a Used Car

Britney Spears In Calgary

Calgary Hit With Snow Fall For 2016

Calgary Car Crashes

Calgary Flood 2013

Calgary in the 1980s

Calgary - Flood 2013 Coverage - Emergency

Calgary Stampede 2013 Live Coverage- WESTNET-HD News Calgary

Calgary Stampede 2014 Live Coverage- WESTNET-HD News Calgary

Calgary Zoo Gorilla Dances

Canadian Radio Show Personality Stuart McLean Has Died

Colorado based REMAX Cashes in on Israel's Illegal Settlements

Crazy Drive-by shooting caught on personal dashcam -Action News Exclusive

Dangerous Zombie Drugs HIits Brazil SCARY

European cities fed up with tourists

FREE Dark Chocolate Dream Latte from Tim Hortons

Fentanyl Drug Kills Over 1000 Calgarians

Girl Throws Puppies Into River

Hien Vu VS Kenneth Qui Retail Problem Calgary CTV

Hot CBS Reporter in Short Skirt Reunites With Truck Driver Who She Saved During Hurricane Harvey

Hot Sexy Britney Spears Pictures

How to Get US Netflix in Canada Easy and Free

How safe are you at a Mexican resort?

Inna - WOW Music Video A Mix Of Movies

Is Islamophobia sweeping the US?

Jennifer Aniston Adopts 33-Year-Old Boyfriend From Africa

Man Fighting Speeding Ticket For Going 1 KM-h Over

Mike Tysons Deserted 80s Mansion

Montreal Bus Police Tow Truck Car Pile Up Leaves 10 Dead

NBC Nightly News Full Broadcast For Sept 20th 2017

NBC Nightly News Full Broadcast For Sept 25th 2017

NBC Nightly News Full Broadcast Tonight For Thursday April 19, 2018

New Evidence Proves 911 Was A Controlled Demolition

New Car Model Design For 2014 Calgary Winter

New ING Direct Canada App Collects Too Much Information

New Super Killer Bee Discovered

Nov. 3, 1997: HDTV Revolution

Overeating could double your chance of memory loss

Petition To Stop Sale of Products Made In The Occupied Territories Launched (Sodastream)

Rihanna In Calgary

Romanian Superstar Inna Crosses into Arabic

Romanian-born Actress Makes Debut on Canadian Television Series

Safeway Customers Being Ripped Off By Weight In Water In Meat

September 11 2001 New Jaw Dropping Video

'Sex And The City' fan sleeps with 1000 men

Sexy Britney Spears - 3 Wardrobe Malfunction in Las Vegas 10-16-15 HOT

Sexy Rihanna Pictures

Shakira - Cant Remember to Forget You ft. Rihanna_(1080p)

Target shuts down in Canada

The Gorgeous Italian Girl Before She Became Lady Gaga

The Greatest Barn Finds Ever

The Highest Quality Vehicles Ever Made

The Ugliest Cars In History

The 'University' of Calgary Does Not Seem To Understand Our Quadrants

The Hottest Girls of 2014 - WESTNET-HD News Calgary

Toronto Becomes First City To Mandate Green Roofs

Tree full of FIRE found-STRANGE VIDEO

Trumps Motorcade Unseen Images

WestNet-HD Live

WestNet-HD Action News -Calgary

WhatsApp for Windows 7 Working Download Trick

Woman Cheats Death 3 Times

Woman says she found a rat sewn into her Zara dress

Worlds largest aircraft prepares to take off looks like a girls Ass

Calgary All Lives Matter

City rolls out black cart program

100 KM long traffic jam in China, is Calgary Next?

Calgary Wind Warning Causes Record Damage

CalgaryFinder.com becomes popular alternative

Is it time for Calgary Eco-Friendly Diaper Company?

Is This Woman Too Hot To Be a Banker?

Haifa Wehbe Survives Suicide Attack

The Health Benefits and Cons of Coffee

How To Avoid Your Mother In Law

How To Fit Back Into Your Favorite Pair of Jeans

Jessica Simpson's dubious 'shock' diet

A Look Back A The 2011 vancouver Hockey Riots

Man Forced To Marry His Girlfriend

McDonald's manager steals 29 tons of McNuggets

McDonald's to end fry rationing

People On Street Pick Up 15 Million Dollars

Sexy CNN reporter makes a bigger fool out of "Christian Preacher" Terry Jones

Kesha Father: "Stop Showing Off Your Butt"

History of the Toyota Land Cruiser (1950-2010)


westnet-hd-sq.png
Copyright 1996-2018 Action News. A Division of WestNet Continental Broadcasting.
News Desk