Councillor calls winter bike commuters 'extreme cyclists,' says Winnipeg shouldn't spend money to clear lanes

Coun. Jeff Browaty says people who ride bikes in Winnipeg during the winter are "extreme cyclists" and says the city should not spend money clearing snow from dedicated bike lanes.

"I don't think Winnipeggers are going to embrace winter cycling," the North Kildonan councillor said Thursday during the final city council meeting of the year.

"The majority of people who are biking in the winter, they're the extreme. They're the extreme cyclists and I don't see that changing."

• Transcona Trail to receive biggest piece of Winnipeg bike infrastructure funding in 2019

Browatymade his comments before council voted to approve $5.4 million of new bike and pedestrian projects slated to be completed in 2019.

Browaty voted in favour of those improvements but warned about the annual cost of clearing snow from dedicated bike lanes in particular.

"These separated barriers are really quite costly in terms of snow removal. There's an expectation they get there very quickly, soI don't think it's a very good use of resources," he told reporters following the council meeting.

"We are a winter city. There is alot of snow in the city and Iwould rather use that money to do a better job of plowing oursidewalks [and]our transportation paths where there is a greater number of people using them."

The city set aside $4 million to clear snow from sidewalks and bike paths this year and has been advised to spend an additional $1 million in 2019.

The precise budget won't be determined until council finance chair Scott Gillingham (St. James) presents a draft budget, likely in February.

• Winnipeggers will wait until May for bike path, sidewalk plowing plan after city report delayed
• City advised to spend nearly $1M more next year to improve sidewalk, bike route snow-clearing

Winnipeg Mayor Brian Bowman said he supports the winter clearing of bike paths and poked fun at Browatyfor voting in favour new bike lanes after sponsoring attack ads against the mayor in 2015 based on the city's plannedactive-transportation infrastructure.

"That's a flip-flopI'll welcome any day," Bowman said.

• Winnipeggers more likely to blame drivers than cyclists for conflict, new poll reveals
• Bike lane pet peeves: Cyclists point out gaps, odd designs in city's network

Winnipeg Trails Association directorIan Frank said it would be unwise to gauge the demand for winter bike paths by looking at the number of people who ride on routes that are not maintained properly.

"If you don't have a protected bike lane that's plowed, no one's going to ride in it," he said.

"We've done a better job than we did even a few years ago, but it's too hit or miss, it's too unreliable. People have a hard timepredicting when they're going to be able to get all the way to work or all the way home."

• OPINIONGive bikes a chance: Winnipeg needs to change so people have transportation choices

Councillor calls winter bike commuters 'extreme cyclists,' says Winnipeg shouldn't spend money to clear lanes

6 years ago

Duration 1:57

Coun. Jeff Browaty says people who ride bikes in Winnipeg during the winter are "extreme cyclists" and says the city should not spend money clearing snow from dedicated bike lanes.