Mike Ward, 'Petit Jrmy' head to human rights tribunal

Quebec comedian Mike Wardwill argue his constitutional right to freedom of expression permits him to make fun of a young man with a condition that causes disfigurement and deformities.

The case washeard on Wednesday morning at the Montreal courthouse.

The family of Jrmy Gabriel made a complaint to the province's human rights tribunal in 2012 after Ward ridiculed the young man in his comedy show,Mike Ward s'eXpose.

Gabriel, who is now 18, became known in Quebecwhen he was flown to Rome to sing for the Pope in 2006.

He has Treacher Collins syndrome, an illness that causes severe disfigurement.

• Quebec boy travels to Rome to sing for Pope
• Little Jrmy sings for pontiff

In Ward's comedy bit, he said he at first humoured the attention Gabriel or as he called him, Petit Jrmy was getting.

"But now, five years later, and he's still not dead! ... Me, I defended him, like an idiot, and he won't die!" Ward said.

Gabriel says videoled to bullying

At the courthouse on Wednesday, Gabriel saidWard went too far in his jokes about him. He said the jokes hurthis confidence and his career, and that it ledto intimidation at his school.

It made me think my life is worth less than another's because I'm handicapped.- Jrmy Gabriel

"At eightIwanted to follow my dreams, accept who I am and surpass it give a message to others that because we're different itdoesn't mean we cantdo what we want to do with our lives," he said.

Gabriel, who has had more than 20 medical procedures to help him with his illness, said the video led him to attempt suicide.

"I was12 or 13 when I saw those videos," Gabriel said. "I didn't have maturity to be strong in the face of thisI lost confidence and hope.It made me think my life is worth less than another's because I'm handicapped."

If Ward is found by the tribunal to have infringed on Gabriel's human rights, he may be ordered to pay Gabriel a sum of money in compensation.

Freedom of expression?

Ward's lawyer, Julius Grey, said his client operated within the established norms of comedy.

"Our position will be that satire and comedy are almost always [mean] and hard. That's the nature of comedy. The position that we will put forward is that there needs to be larger artistic freedoms," he said.

But Quebec law professor Louis-Philippe Lampron said Ward should have exercised better judgment in choosing Gabriel, a non-public person with an obvious illness, as a target.

"Not only is he not a public personality who should have a thicker skin for criticism or caricatures, but the opposite: He's a vulnerable and identifiable person," Lampron said.

He added that this isn't a matter of putting freedom of expression on trial, but rather a particular case involving a particular person.

Meanwhile, Grey said that the case against Ward is a sign of the country moving backwards on matters of freedom of expression.