How often do Quebec MNAs show up to vote at the National Assembly? - Action News
Home WebMail Tuesday, November 26, 2024, 01:22 PM | Calgary | -8.3°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Montreal

How often do Quebec MNAs show up to vote at the National Assembly?

Premier Philippe Couillard was present 71 per cent of the time during voting, less than his predecessors Pauline Marois and Jean Charest.

New data compiled by The Canadian Press takes a look at voting attendance since 2014

Quebec Premier Philippe Couillard, right, and Parti Quebecois Leader Jean-Francois Lisee, shakes hands at end of the spring session on Friday at the National Assembly. (Jacques Boissinot/Canadian Press)

Since the 2014 provincial election, Liberal members of the National Assembly have had the highest voting attendance as a whole, according to new data obtained and analyzedby the Canadian Press.

The Canadian Press pulled attendance information and crunched the numbers onwhich politicians were present for voting on bills and motions from 2014 to last Tuesday.

The data shows that LiberalMNAsare the most present of all, with an average voting attendance of 89 per cent.

LiberalMNAsPierre Michel Augerand Guy Hardyhad the highest of anyone, withan average rate of 98 per cent.

Liberal MNA for the riding of Champlain, Pierre Michel Auger. (Radio-Canada)

The Canadian Pressnotes that these calculations are not a perfect representation of overall attendance at the National Assembly and don't account for anMNA'spresence during question period, participation in parliamentary committees or any work-related external activities.

Couillard falling behind

Since his election victory in 2014, Premier Philippe Couillard was present 71 per cent of the time during voting, less than his predecessors Pauline Marois (with 76 per cent) and Jean Charest (with 89 per cent from 2009 to 2012).

This could be explained by Couillard's semi-regular trips abroad, including one to Morocco last November during which he missed three votes. Days later, he took another trip to Paris.

French President Francois Hollande, left, welcomes Quebec Premier Philippe Couillard prior to their meeting at the Elysee Palace in Paris on Nov. 23, 2016. (Francois Mori/The Associated Press)

Another consideration to note is that Pauline Marois was premier for only 18 months, whereas Couillardhas been premier for three years.

"The premier was present in the National Assembly chamber as well as internationally to promote what our workers, entrepreneurs, and researchers do," said Couillard's spokesperson Harold Fortin.

Opposition jugglingportfolios

MNAs representing the other three main parties in the province were not far behind the Liberals.

PartiqubcoisMNAAgnsMaltaisandCoalitionavenirQubec'sNathalie Roy also sharedtop numbers with 96 per cent.

Meanwhile,Qubecsolidaire'sManonMasscame out with an average 82 percent since 2014.
Manon Mass is the co-spokesperson for Qubec Solidaire and representative for the riding of Sainte-MarieSaint-Jacques. (Radio-Canada)

Qubec solidaireMNAAmir Khadirfared less well with an almost65 per cent voting rate.Aspokesperson for his party told CP that it's important to take into account the workload for representatives from smaller parties.

"MNAs for other parties usually participate in only one commission, or serve as the critic for only one dossier. That's not the case with our MNAswho each are responsible for nearly a dozen dossiers and participate in multiple commissions," lise Tanguaytold The Canadian Press in an email.

Khadiralso took several trips outside of Quebec, meeting with politicians in Brussels and in Mexico.

Wearing two hats

Martine Ouellet, who became leader of the BlocQubcoisin March, chose to stay on asan independent MNA in her South Shore riding of Vachonrather than force a byelection.
Martine Ouellet has a voting record of around 70 per cent. (Jacques Boissinot/Canadian Press)

The numbers showOuelletmissed 11 of 42 votes since taking on the role of leader in March, including votes on three bills and a nomination of the ethics commissioner.

Ouellet'spress attachconfirmed she was out of the province twice due to her new role in Ottawa, for the federal budget announcement and for last week's emergency caucus meeting.

Overall, she has a voting record of around 70 per cent. Her office noted thatOuelletalso missed time due to an operation on her knee and due to her father's declining health.

Working abroad

Some MNAs, including the Minister of International Relations, Christine St-Pierre, were less present in the National Assembly because of work-related trips outside of Quebec. St-Pierre participated in 71 per cent of the votes.

Other Liberal MPs including Guy Ouellette, Robert Poti and Julie Bouletwere absent due to parliamentary missions abroad as well. PQ MNAs AlexandreCloutier and Mathieu Traversyalso took trips abroad for work.

Valid excuses

When it came to MNAs whose records were below average, many were found to haveexcuses relating to health issues and work-related travel.
Treasury Board President Pierre Moreau missed months of work due to ongoing health issues. (Radio-Canada)

For instance, Treasury Board PresidentPierre Moreaumissed full months of work because he was dealing with health issues.

This was similarly the case for MNAsKarine Vallires(Richmond), Raymond Bernier(Montmorency) andJean Rousselle(Vimont).

Political science professor atUniversit Laval ricMontigny highlights the "enormous" amount of work done by MNAs, citing his own findings that Quebec politicians work more diligently than their counterparts in Ottawa or even France.

"The vast majority of these MNAs work 80-hour weeks," he said. "There are misconceptions about the workload of being an MNA and the constraints this imposes on their personal lives."


The Canadian Press notes that these figures do not paint a clear picture of the total work of an MNA and that there are many valid reasons why an elected representative might have cause to miss time in the National Assembly.

The data was collected using an algorithm developed by The Canadian Press to search the logs of the National Assembly one by one. The data collection and number crunching that followed accounted for MNAs who left their posts early or were elected later on in byelections.

In addition, journalists at CP went on to verify certain facts personally by consulting the transcripts and videos made available online.

Based on a report by CP's Vicky Fragasso-Marquis, Dominique Degr and Mick Ct