New Brunswick slammed as 'grinch that stole' a national health accord

New Brunswick is being both criticized and lauded for reaching its own agreement on health care funding with the federal government.

The Canadian Health Coalition dubbed the province "the grinch that stole a national health accord," after Premier Brian Gallant announced the deal on Thursday.

"By negotiating their own bilateral agreement, N.B. may have weakened the ability of other provinces to negotiate a stronger health accord," Adrienne Silnicki,nationalco-ordinator of the public advocacy organization dedicated to the protection and improvement of medicare,said in a statement.

• New Brunswick secures $230M more for health care from Ottawa over 10 years
• Brian Gallant chooses alignment with Trudeau over fellow premiers

"Provinces like Ontario require a 5.2% [Canadian Health Transfer payment] tocontinue offering their current basket of health care services," saidSilnicki.

"All of us are at risk of seeing our public health care system significantly weakened if these types of bilateral arrangements continue."

The New Brunswick deal the first reached since talks between federal and provincial governments broke down earlier this week includes $230 million in additional funding for home care and mental-health care over the next 10 years.

Under the deal, the annual CanadaHealth Transfer payments to the province will increase by three per cent per yearor at the rate of national GDP growth, whichever is higher.

It represents an estimated annual increase of 4.1 per cent "the middle ground" between the 3.5 per cent that the federal government had been offering and the provinces' counter-offer of 5.2 per cent, Gallant saidduring a news conference in Fredericton.

"It's exactly what we needed and exactly what we wanted," he said.

$659 millionin losses alleged

The Canadian Health Coalition, however, contends New Brunswick will lose about$659 million with this bilateral agreement, compared to if the province hadnegotiated with the other premiers to keep the current six per centtransfer until 2024.

The coalition "continues to call for the federal, provincial and territorial governments to return to the Health Accord negotiation table and work out a deal that is in the best interest of all Canadians," the statement said.

The Canadian Medical Association, which represents physicians across the country, meanwhile, is applauding the New Brunswick agreement, which itsays will "address the urgent needs of the aging population" in the provinceby investing in "key programs."

"We hope today's bilateral agreement will open the door to further discussions among other provincial and territorial governments, and to finding common ground that benefits Canadian patients," association president Dr. Granger Avery said in a statement.

More bilateral deals being discussed

Federal Health Minister Jane Philpotttold CBC Power & Politics guest hostTerry Milewskishe will not be surprised if other bilateral agreements reached.

"I believe there are quite a few discussions going on" between the federal government and other provinces and territories, she said.

I think we'll be hearing more good news on that in the days and weeks to come.- Jane Philpott, federal health minister

"I've certainly had a couple of conversations with my counterparts and I believe [Finance] Minister [Bill]Morneau has had other conversations as well."

Philpott said she hopes to see deals signed "sooner rather than later."

"There are people who are waiting now for access to care so, the sooner we can come to those agreements, the more assurance we can have that those resources will flow to provinces and territories ideally with our spring budget and I think we'll be hearing more good news on that in the days and weeks to come," she said.

Will other provinces cut deals with the feds on health?

8 years ago

Duration 8:36

'It will not surprise me if there are further bilateral agreements,' says federal Health Minister Jane Philpott.