Thousands are still in the dark after Fiona. Here's how Canada can protect its power grid - Action News
Home WebMail Tuesday, November 26, 2024, 10:55 AM | Calgary | -16.2°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Politics

Thousands are still in the dark after Fiona. Here's how Canada can protect its power grid

Experts say Canada's electrical grid needs some serious investment and reinvention if it's going to bothexpand massively in a bid to fight climate change andbecome more resilient to natural disasters.

Grid hardening, regional integration should be key priorities for investment, experts say

A street is littered with downed utility poles and power lines.
Joshawa Tyler LaVoie captured this striking image of downed power lines and poles on Woodlawn Road in Dartmouth, N.S. (Submitted by Joshawa Tyler LaVoie)

Experts say Canada's electrical grid needs some serious investment and reinvention if it's going to bothexpand massively in a bid to fight climate change and become more resilient to natural disasters.

Post-tropical storm Fiona, which left hundreds of thousands of people without power in Atlantic Canada, is just the latest in a long series of natural disasters which left Canadians without electricity.

"I learned how to go camping again. You just kind of get used to it. You understand there's people out there that have had a lot worse than we have. So we just sort of wait for our turn for the power to come back on and get back to some semblance of normal," said Lee Fleury, a P.E.I. resident left without power for over a week in Fiona's wake. Many people in Atlantic Canada still do not have electricity.

But Canada needs a new normal if it's going to both significantly increase energy production and secure it against potential disasters, two experts told CBC Radio'sThe Housein an interview airing Saturday.

LISTEN: How Canada can build an electrical grid for the future:

Canadas electrical grids are facing more extreme weather events and a massive expansion of demand in the coming decades. Energy experts Kristen van de Biezenbos and Bruce Lourie discuss how to make the system both bigger and more resilient.

Bruce Lourie, president of the environmental organization the Ivey Foundation, said Canada will need to double or triple electricity capacityby roughly2050 to keep up with growing demand in part spurred by new electrification pushes for things like electric vehicles.

"Electric cars, electric heat pumps in homes, more electrification in industry. So it's a big, big task ahead of us," he told host Catherine Cullen.

Storms highlight grid vulnerabilities

Canada has long enjoyeda relatively green electrical system which getsover 80 per cent of its powerfrom non-emittingsources. But Lourie said Canada still faces a challenge in rapidly expanding the grid.

"In part, I think that's made us a little bit complacent," he said. "So I don't know if we're really set up for this big task ahead of us."

Part of that taskalso involves making sure that the grid is more resilient against natural disasters of the type that left hundreds of thousands of people in Atlantic Canada in the dark after Fiona.

"What storms do really is point out the vulnerabilities of the system. So the vulnerabilities are there. The storms just make it very real and make the impact felt by the local people who lose their power," Lourie said.

He saidCanada must invest in projects that"harden" transmission or create "micro grids" of smaller, independently powered systems.

Kristen van de Biezenbos, an associate professor at the University of Calgary specializing in energy law, said one focus for resiliency-boosting efforts would be to bury power linesrather than have them strung along poles.

But paying for those changes could be"a bit tricky," she said, since private provincial utilities (such as Maritime Electric in P.E.I. or Nova Scotia Power) may have incentives different from those motivating Crown corporations.

"Building more infrastructure is going to cost money and making changes to the system to make it more resilient is also going to cost money," she said.

Both experts said that while adding renewable, resilient power capacity hasa big upfront cost, it likely wouldbe cheaper over time.

A need for inter-provincial collaboration

One factor to consider, van de Biezenbos said, is that the federal governmenttraditionally has played a minor role in energy transmission infrastructure, leavingmost of the work to provinces.

The federal government has set itself goals for boosting electricity production and improving the grid. National Resources Canada has a smart grid program to improve efficiency and reliability, for example, and the government's emissions reductions plan also includes a section on electricity.

Part of that plan calls for "accelerating the development of transformational, nation-building, inter-provincial transmission lines" connecting provinces so that electricity can be moved more easily within Canada.

That's been a dim prospect in the past,van de Biezenbos said.

"There hasn't been any pressure from the federal government to make that happen," she said. "And the provinces are ... saying that they don't really see the economic benefits and that their own ratepayers are not interested in spending money to connect to other provinces."

Lourie noted that Canada lagsbehind peer countries in the type of regional planning that would connect more areas across jurisdictions. National Resources Canada has established what it calls the Regional Energy and Resource Tables, which seekto promote collaboration between provinces and between Ottawa and the provinces.

In a statement to CBC News, a spokesperson for Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson said that in a future greeneconomy, "a clean and affordable power grid one that is resilient to increasingly severe climate hazards is a massive competitive advantage."

"Minister Wilkinson is laser-focused on working with provinces, territories, Indigenous partnersand others to secure that advantage for every region of Canada," said director of communications Ian Cameron.

The Atlantic Loop would expand the electrical grid connections between Quebec and New Brunswick and New Brunswick and Nova Scotia to provide greater access to renewable electricity, like hydro from Quebec.
The Atlantic Loop would expand electrical grid connections between Quebec and New Brunswick, and New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, to provide greater access to renewable electricity, such as hydro from Quebec. (CBC)

The proposed Atlantic Loop, which would connect four provinces, is one example of that kind of collaboration, and premiers have called on the federal government to decide whether it will fund the estimated $5 billion project.

"The greater the integration across systems, the greater the areas, the greater the diversity of supply ultimately the greater the resilience," Lourie said.

While regional integration has not been the norm in the past, van de Biezenbossaid there'sreason to hope that this may be changing now. Where once the feeling was "it wasn't really going to happen," she said, there appears to be some recent momentum.

"But it would be a big break from the way things have been done traditionally in Canada and expensive."

Clarifications

  • This article has been updated to clarify that there are multiple Regional Energy and Resource Tables.
    Oct 08, 2022 11:49 AM ET

Corrections

  • This article has been updated from a previous version which stated Kristen van de Biezenbos was an associate professor with the University of Alberta. In fact, she is an associate professor with the University of Calgary.
    Oct 13, 2022 10:22 PM ET

Add some good to your morning and evening.

Your weekly guide to what you need to know about federal politics and the minority Liberal government. Get the latest news and sharp analysis delivered to your inbox every Sunday morning.

...

The next issue of Minority Report will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in theSubscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.