Pierre Poilievre called lobbyists 'utterly useless,' but they're still attending his fundraisers

As Pierre Poilievre presents himself as both a prime minister in waiting and a champion of "the working-class people," he's headlined roughly 50 fundraisers at private venues since becoming Conservative leader in 2022 some of them in Canada's wealthiest neighbourhoods and most exclusive clubs.

A CBC News analysis of fundraising reports the Conservatives submitted to Elections Canada show these fundraisers haveattracted dozens of registered federal lobbyists who paid up to $1,725 each to attend events featuring Poilievre.

Business executives including a billionaire oil tycoon, an airline executive and a vice president at AtkinsRalis, formerly known as SNC-Lavalin are on the lists of attendees.

These fundraisers are legal and have a long historyin Canadian politics. In a statement issued to CBC News, a Conservative Party spokesperson said Poilievremakes himself available at events across the country and there's no need to attend a fundraiser to get access to him.

But suchfundraisers have ledto media scrutiny and opposition criticism in the past some of it comingfrom Poilievre.

Poilievre has criticized Prime Minister Justin Trudeau overhis fundraising events in the past. He describedone event in 2019 as a "$1,500 ticket fundraiser where he was speaking to a bunch of well-connected Liberal lobbyists and wealthy donors."

Last Friday, Poilievre publishedan opinion piecein the National Postcalling on corporate Canada to fire its lobbyists, describing them as "useless and overpaid."

Poilievre criticized lobbyists in the article, saying the only way"any business lobby has born fruit" has been through "undue handouts, privileges and protections" that "Justin Trudeau has been all too willing to grant." He said businesses will "get nothing from me unless they convince the people first."

WATCH |Poilievre calls lobbyists 'useless' but still headlines fundraisers they attend

Poilievre calls lobbyists 'useless' but still headlines fundraisers they attend

4 months ago

Duration 2:15

A CBC News analysis of Conservative Party fundraising reports found Pierre Poilievre has headlined at least 50 private fundraisers since becoming party leader, some attended by corporate lobbyists he publicly criticizes.

The Liberal Party's fundraising practicescame under scrutinyin 2016when the Globe and Mail revealed Prime Minister Trudeau attended a fundraiser with a Chinese businessman who went on to donate $200,000 to the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation.

To ward off claimsthe Liberals were giving wealthy donors preferential access to Trudeau and his cabinet, the party changed its policy in 2017 to limitthese events to publicly available spaces and to allow journalists access.

The government also changed the law in 2018 to requirethat partiesmake these fundraisers more transparent by posting online notices in advance andreportingdetails, includinglists of attendees, to Elections Canada.

The Conservatives said they were "concerned" about the bill earlier that yearand later votedagainst it. Then-finance critic Grard Deltell said these fundraisers were "unethical" and would legalize what he called "cash-for-access, or paying to get access to decision-makers."

Poilievrecallslobbyists 'utterly useless'

The National Post article is not the first instance ofPoilievreaccusingbusiness leaders of trying to cozy up to the governing Liberal Party.

In December, Poilievre expressed disdain for Bay Street executives, saying he "almost never" speaks to crowds in downtown Toronto or "anywhere close to Bay Street."

Fundraising records show Poilievre has headlined three fundraisers for the Conservative Party on Bay Street and at least four others in downtown Toronto since 2023.

In March,Poilievre told the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade that, rather than speaking to business associations like it, he's appeared at "110 shop floors and five union local facilities." He said his experience with corporate lobbyists in Ottawa has "been that they have been utterly useless in advancing any common sense interests for the people on the ground."

Poilievre said these lobbyists are focused on getting lunches with ministersat the elite Rideau Club atop a downtown Ottawa office tower.

"When I'm prime minister, my obsession my daily obsession will be about what is good for the working class people of this country," Polievre said during his speech on March 8.

CBC News examinedthe lists of attendees on the Conservatives'fundraising reports filed with Elections Canada since Poilievre became leader in September2022. CBCcross-referenced those listswith names in the federal lobbyist registry, then verified the names of lobbyists directly or through cross-referencing publicly available information.

• Example of fundraising report from 'An Evening with Pierre Poilievre' in Banff

• What are regulated fundraising events?

CBC News found that more than 25 active federal lobbyists have attended these fundraisers since Poilievrebecameleader in 2022. The names of morethan 100 inactive (but still registered) federal lobbyistsmatched those of listedattendeesat these fundraisers during that time frame.

The Breach conducted an analysis in March and reported thatout of the 35 Poilievrefundraising events it examined, 29 were attended by at least one lobbyist active in the past several years.

NDP ethics critic Matthew Green saidhis problem is with the "hypocrisy of Pierre Poilievre." Green accused Poilievre of "cosplaying as a working class guy"while privately attending fundraisers in exclusive clubs "most Canadians would have never heard of."

"This is a guy who is not who he says he is," Green told CBC News. "This is somebody who is the 'elites' that he rails against."

CBC News contacted the Conservative Partyand Poilievre's office with questions about the fundraisers.

In an email, the Conservatives accused CBC News of "exposing its bias by investigating Canadians, who are supporting common sense Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre and his promise to defund the CBC."

Sarah Fischer, a spokesperson for the Conservative Party, told CBC News in an email that Poilievremakes "himself available across the country at rallies, visiting small businesses, lumber yards and factory floors.

"There's no need to attend a fundraiser to get access to Pierre Poilievre."

Big pharma, an oil 'tycoon' and top Canadian executives

Active lobbyists representing the oil and natural gas company Cenovus, Pharmascience Inc.and the Pembina Pipeline Corporation are among those listed as having attended Poilievre fundraisers.

Other lobbyists from the shipbuilding, energy and pharmaceutical industriesconfirmed their attendance to CBC News.

Adam Waterous, recently described in a media report as an "investment banker turned oil tycoon," is listed as having attended a Poilievre event with his wife Jan andson Connor, who lobbies, in April 2023 in Banff, Alta.,where he owns a ski resort.

Waterous has not yet responded to CBC's request for comment.

Robert Deluce, thefounding president and former CEO of Porter Airlines, attended a fundraiser in January 2023, co-organized by Mark Mulroney, the son of former prime minister Brian Mulroney. Deluce now serves as the company's executive chairman.

A spokesperson for the airline told CBC News Deluce contributed to the fundraiser "in a personal capacity" and spoke briefly to Poilievre but not about Porter.

Poilievre supports a runway expansion to bring jets to the Billy Bishop airport in Toronto something Porter has long sought.

Erik Ryan, a vice president at AtkinsRalis, formerly known as SNC-Lavalin, attended a reception in January with Poilievre and toldCBC News he gave a personal contribution. Ryan was involved in a lobbying effort to get a deferred prosecution agreement for SNC-Lavalin from the federal government.

Ian Stedman, an associate professor of public law and governance at York University, said the "public should care about these events and who's there."

"It tells you something about who has privileged access to a politician who might have the ability to affect change or advance policy initiatives," Stedman said.

Stedman said "lobbying is not bad" but"the problem here is that some people get better access and more preferential access than others, and it seems to be because of the money they have."

But Fred DeLorey, the national Conservative campaign manager during the 2021 election, said lobbying at these fundraisers is "unheard of."

DeLorey, who is a lobbyist himself, said it "would be very poor form to try to bend the ear of a leader at a place like that."

Askedwhether those attendingthese fundraisers would get increased access to political leaders, Delorey said no.

There's a strict limit on how much individual Canadians are allowedto give to a federal political party each year. In 2024, the limit is $1,725.

"There's no political influence on cutting a check at that amount to a leader that's trying to govern a G7 country," said DeLorey, who is a partner at NorthStar Public Relations and Government Relations. "It's just not a thing."

Riding high in the polls, the Conservative Party of Canada continues to out-fundraise other parties and broke its own record in the most recent quarter. The party raised more than $10.6 million from more than 51,000 donors between January and March.

About 700 of those donors attended fundraising events with Poilievre fundraiserswhich could have collected up to $1millionduring that time period. Fischerdid not answer when askedhowmuch money the party collectedin 2023 and over the first quarter of this year at fundraisers Poilievre headlined.

Shesaid that out of 200,000 contributions, the average donation to the Conservatives was$175.

"Hundreds of thousands of Canadians are choosing to put their hard-earned dollars behind Pierre Poilievre and his mission to axe the tax, build the homes, fix the budget and stop the crime," she said in an email.

Private clubs

Poilievre has headlinedfundraisersat Canada's oldest private club the Toronto Club atthe members-only Terminal City Clubin Vancouverand at the Royal Glenora Club in Edmonton, where thefee for a membership is more than $20,000.

Poilievrehas headlined more than 16 fundraisers in private homessince becoming leader, including in one of Montreal's wealthiest neighbourhood Westmount and affluent neighbourhoods in the greater Toronto area. Another one is booked for later this week in North York.

One of these"Evenings with Pierre Poilievre in support of the Conservative Party'' took place at a home in Forest Hill South in Toronto, the records show. Two homes are for sale in the same postal code withasking prices of $7.5 million and $16.9 million.

Poilievre also has been touring the country holding public events and fundraisersin local businesses and restaurants.

'Like a town hall meeting'

Yaroslav Baran, co-founder of Pendulum Group and former Conservative director of war room communications under prime minister Stephen Harper, said there's a "mythology" aroundthese fundraisers that doesn't reflect reality.

"People picture cigars, brandysnifters and mahogany furniture," said Baran who ran communications for the Conservative Party during the 2022 leadership race.

"It's really a lot like a town hall meeting except it's a closed event. You need to buy a ticket to get in. It usually consists of a mini speech, a stump speech by the featured speaker."

Baran said what follows after that is "an endless stream of grip-and-grin" photos, where the headlining politician shakes hands, smiles for the camera and then moves on to the next person with about two or three seconds to exchange a few words.

"The idea of being able to have any kind of a prolonged, deep policy conversation to, you know, sway somebody, it's just laughable," he said.

Lobbyists go to these events to build relationships and be seen, Baran said. But he cautions that if they're looking tolobbysomeone directly, they shouldn't go to their partyfundraisers.

Trudeau attended 14 of these events to raise moneyfor the Liberal Party in 2023 and one so far in 2024, held at convention centres, hotels and the Canadian War Museum. Last year, the Investigative Journalism Foundation reported that 166 lobbyists have attended Liberal fundraisers since 2019.

Liberal Party spokesperson Parker Lund said the party is "committed to the strongest standards in federal politics for openness and transparency with political fundraising events." The party also posts its fundraising reports on its website.

In 2021, Lobbying Commissioner Nancy Blanger made preliminary recommendations to strengthen the lobbying regime, callingfor expanding the amount of contextual information requiredin communication reports to include things likepolitical donations.

Ethics Commissioner Konrad von Finckensteinhas described the current reporting requirements forthese fundraisers as "perfectly good." He said thatif the government wants to, it could go further and legislate its existing fundraising and lobbyingbest practices for ministers and parliamentary secretaries to coveropposition critics.