Blood, gore and nudity: Why graphic content shows up in your newsfeed - Action News
Home WebMail Tuesday, November 26, 2024, 10:59 AM | Calgary | -16.2°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Science

Blood, gore and nudity: Why graphic content shows up in your newsfeed

Scroll down your newsfeed and chances are you will see some pretty graphic content shootings, blood, gore. So just how does this content end up there?

Child pornography, human trafficking, drug and gun sales are off limits

A video of a rapper shooting himself through a cheek got promoted by Facebook Newswire this week, while this photo of a father and son in a shower got pulled and reinstated several times earlier this year. (Kasper Knight/Facebook/Submitted by Heather Whitten)

Take a quick scrolldown your newsfeed todayandyou'll likely see news about the U.S.Democratic convention, the latest Donald Trumprallyand Pokemon Go.

But sprinkled between theseis more graphic content recent examples include photos of the woundedbloodydentist who got attacked by a sharkor thevideo of a rapper shooting himself through thecheekfor a music video.

Both posts were full of blood andsome severelymangled skin, and were gory to stumble upon. So how did these end up in yournewsfeed?

Despite the blood and gore, neither post goes against Facebook's community standards or Twitter's media policy. The content is graphic and many may not like it, but the companies keep it online.

Both posts were actually being promoted this week by Facebook Newswire a service used tohelp newsrooms find stories that are trending on social media and were written by many different media outlets.

The shark post had a small graphic warning written in its caption, though the bloody photos could be seen regardless. The shooting was given a "graphic warning" bumper ahead of the video, meaning it didn't automatically start playing or show up in the newsfeeds of minors.

This graphic warning appears as a bumper at the start of the video of the rapper shooting himself through the cheek. Users must click on the play button to start the video. The graphic warning means it doesn't show up in the newsfeeds of minors. (Facebook)

There havebeencountless other examples ofgraphic content showing up in newsfeeds the bloody aftermath of thePhilando Castile shootingin Minnesota during a routine traffic stopwas streamed on Facebook,and the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)has used Twitter to post gruesome content.

Facebookand Twitter say it islargely up to users to self-censor content such asthisbefore they post itonline that can be done by marking it as sensitive material andgivingcontext in the caption.Otherwise, they warn there'sa chance it might be flagged by another user and taken down.

Child porn, trafficking no-go

If offensive or graphic content isreportedtoFacebookor Twitter, the posts are reviewed by their moderation teams.

Much like newsrooms make editorial judgments, these moderators must decide if there's value to the flagged content or if it oversteps the company's rules and guidelines which they are expected to know intimately.

Any content that includes child pornography, human trafficking, orselling drugs and gunsis offlimits.

Both companies rely on their users to report any problem posts. Twitter-owned Periscope has takenthis a step further it has implemented "flash juries," arandomly selected group of users during a livestream who judge whether a flagged comment is acceptable or not.

Depending on time ofday, content is reviewedin different Facebook and Twitter offices around the world. Policies remain the same worldwide, but because it comes down to the judgment of an individualmoderator, cultural differences may factor in.

For example, a moderator reviewing contentat Facebook's offices in India may make different decisions about theflagged content thana moderator working at Facebook's offices in Austin, Texas.

Facebook photo brought CPS

Sometimes moderators make mistakes.

Arizona-based photographer Heather Whitten takes photos of her four kids sometimes they are topless or not wearing bottoms. She hashad some of thesepulled and then reinstated onFacebook several times. Her Instagram account has also been banned.

Her most controversial photo was one she posted on Facebook of her husband comfortingheryoung son in their shower. Her kid was violently ill with salmonella poisoning. The photo was taken in 2014, but Whittenonlyposted it in May on her Facebook page, where it went viral.

Thomas Whitten comforts his ill son, Fox, in their shower in 2014. The photo was posted online in May 2016, where it was pulled and reinstated by Facebook several times. It does not violate the site's guidelines. (Submitted by Heather Whitten)

The photo didn't violate Facebook'snudity guidelines,but it kept getting reported and taken down by the site. Whitten said she didn't get any notices from Facebook and they never reached out to explain what happened.

"It never crossed my mind that it would be controversial or anything because it's just so normal in our life,so it always kind of takes me aback a little bit," she told CBC News.

Three weeks after she posted the shower photo,Child Protective Services showed up at her door and said someone had anonymously reported her photos. CPS conducted an investigation andinterviewed the family, but found nothing.

"That really shook us," she said. "We're very desensitized to violence ... but when there's nudity or intimacy, we really shut that down."

This photo was also pulled from Facebook, but unlike the others, was never reinstated. Pictured are Whitten's two daughters, Lillian and Leena, playing one morning in the bathroom. (Submitted by Heather Whitten)

Whitten said she hasn't been sharing much online sinceand is still trying to figure out where her style of photography fits on social media.

"I definitely do still feel very passionate that these kinds of images should be allowed and there should be kind of like a normalization," she said.

"[Photographers]need social media. We love social media. We just kind of want it reciprocated a little bit."