I don't think they need to give out mp3 copies of the songs. That is an unnecessary expense for Harmonix (and/or Activision I guess) considering they have been selling well at the given prices.

I know I buy the songs to play them in the game, not to listen to.

Who is complaining about $2.50 for a game extension? I mean really, what is being downloaded here is not intended to be listened to - it's not meant to make you want to download the song. This is a game, and the download is to add functionality to that game. The idea is that the user likely already enjoys the song, and would like to also be able to play it.

Besides, programming each song is not as simple as allowing an automated system to process an mp3.

We're kind of talking about apples and oranges here. I agree that GH and Rock Band tunes are a little too pricey, but I have no problem with them being meant to be played solely with the game. Not much grumbling had been heard concerning the songs that come included with the game, or songs that can be purchased afterwards, but all of a sudden some people feel entitled to more when it comes to a new single being released via videogame. To me it's kind of like going out to a movie and expecting to get a copy of the DVD just because we're paying to see the movie.

I think it's ridiculous how they wish to sell mp3's with the downloadable content. Rather pointless. Also takes up room on a 360's/ PS3's hardrive that some people might NOT have room for. I'm looking for more songs to play not listen too. This is the most reasonable way for a game utilising music, or else we would end up with 60+ version of Rock Band and/or Guitar Hero (Kind of like Sport games) except they could have a game made probabley for every day until the end of time.

You pay for what you get and extra's will cost more. Nothing in life is for free. People need to stop being so greedy, and get a job so they can purchase these things like a 'normal person' should. (Illegal limewire downloading fools).

Well... why would you want 'free music' with a game, where the point of the game is to 'play' it on a peripheral instrument controller? I mean if you really want these songs there are ways you can purchase them. If you really want to download these songs and save them on your 360 hard drives, there is a special license you can buy so you can import all tracks onto your hard drive through Rock band on the 360. You can also buy the Rock band travel pack; I think it features all songs on three CDs. Giving free songs is rather pointless in a video game, which is why I have an iPod, or I use my computer

Overall, Garets statement puts the nail in the coffin; I buy the songs to play them in the game, not to listen to. Cmon folks, its a Video game!